|
Editor's
Note:
In 1998, I wrote an
article entitled Building Your Cottage Recording
Studio. The article gives the basics and
details about installing a project studio in your
garage. Then in 2004 I used these plans to
build Sage Ct. Studios in Ann Arbor, MI.
Nothing beats doing it right.
The Problem:
Many people have
put "home recording studios" in their basement. The
basement home recording studio is fun, but has
inherent difficulties when trying to use it as a
cottage studio, as follows:
1. The ceilings are
usually to low to provide the best sound and
isolation form the living area of the house.
2. It is difficult
to
isolate
the family activities of (for example) using
the kitchen or laundry area, from interfering with
the studio operation.
3. It is difficult
to isolate traffic from the living area of the
house. Many spouses will object to "clients"
wandering through the house.
The Solution:
Many houses have an
associated building called a "Garage." The garage
usually houses the car, the lawn mower, and a bunch
of junk. The lawn mower and garden tools/equipment
can go into an inexpensive shed next to the garage.
The car can be parked in the driveway and the junk
can go in the basement. The cottage studio can go in
the garage.
With its higher
ceilings (usually 8 feet) and large area (usually 24
feet by 20 feet), its peaked roof, and its isolation
from the house, it is a much more suitable area for
a studio than the basement. Famous professional
studios have started in the garage.
Disclaimer
This plan is a
guideline that the author feels will provide
acceptable results. Before actually starting
construction, one must check with local authorities
to make sure the construction will meet local
building and zoning codes. Permits and licenses may
be necessary to legally start construction or use
the facility once it is built.
Local,
legally-binding, codes vary a great deal from one
area to another. Urban areas tend to be more
restrictive than rural areas. Because of this, it is
also suggested that you get some legal advice from a
local attorney. A clerk in a city office may want to
put you through more red tape than you legally have
to endure. An attorney may help you fill out
applications with the least hassle from authorities
Assumptions &
Basic Floor Plan:
We are assuming
that you have a stand-alone or attached garage that
measures 20'x22' with a peaked rood and on a
concrete slab. Sizes of garages vary from 20'x20' to
22'x24' which means the basic floor plan may have to
be modified slightly to fit your garage size.
Surveying a national building supply chain, we found
the 20'x22' to be the most common size.
Figure 1
shows how the total area has been subdivided to 5
areas for effective band recording:
Room 1: The Studio
area that measures approximately 16'x10' that would
be used for the drums and musicians for recording.
Room 2: The Control
Room area, measuring 11'4"x7'.
Room 3: A main
isolation booth of approximately 5'6"x4" that can be
used for guitar or vocals during the session.
Room 4: A 3'x4'
closet area for storage of studio equipment and that
can be used as a second guitar booth.
Room 5: A 8'6"x8'
"Entrance area" that can be used as an office or
divided up into storage lockers for tapes and
control room supplies. This area can also be an
"emergency" isolation room.
This plan assumes
you want to be able to record bands with live drums.
If you expect your studio to specialize is
MIDI work with
synthesizers and
drum machines, the
larger room could be the control room and Room 2
could function as a small studio/large isolation
room. You could still do drums in a pinch, but
musician eye contact would be harder to achieve.
Keeping Room 1 as the Studio will yield a better
drum sound.
Room
Dimensions:
The first two rooms
(Studio and Control Room) are carefully modified
from the ancient
Golden Section
dimensions. A Golden Section is an area that has a
specific ratio of height to width to depth. The
ratio is approximately 1 (high) by 1.6 (deep) by 2.6
(wide). When a room conforms to these dimensions, it
will evenly reflect all frequencies so that any area
sounds substantially the same. The
ambience in the
room will reinforce the
tone of the
instruments rather that sounding "muddy" or "thin".
In smaller studios,
it becomes impossible to strictly maintain the
Golden Section dimensions. Often the ceiling would
be too low to be practical. If you take one of the
surfaces of the room and increase the dimensions
(like ceiling height) and you can maintain much of
the Golden Section
acoustics
if you make the surface evenly
absorb all
frequencies. With
this modification, 5 of the six surfaces will evenly
reflect the frequencies and the 6th
surface will not reflect sound. If you need to
modify the room dimensions to fit your specific
garage, keep the room 1.6 times wider that the depth
to maintain the Golden Section acoustics.
General
Construction Techniques:
We will get as
specific as room allows for this article.
Unfortunately, we don't have the room to get to
every detail.
Shell
Preparation
The garage will
need some modifications to prevent as much sound
leakage into the
neighborhood as possible.
The side door of
the garage may have to be moved into the right area,
although it should be approximately correct without
moving it. You will probably want to replace the
door with a well fitting, solid-core door with
proper weather stripping to make an air-tight seal.
Often the door is only 30 inches wide, and you may
want to modify the opening to accept a 36" wide
door.
Garages often have
small windows. Any window should be removed and the
open area framed in and covered to match the normal
garage wall.
The garage door
should be fastened shut and get an air-tight seal
around the entire opening. The opening for the door
should be framed in so that the area has studs, just
like the other walls.
In the area where
the roof meets the walls, there is usually an air
gap of 1/2 to 1". This allows the garage to
"breathe". These areas should be well-stuffed with
high-quality fiberglass isolation.
The entire wall and
roof surface should be closely inspected and sealed
with caulk so that there is an air-tight seal to the
outside world in all areas except where the roof
meets the walls. Pay particular attention to how the
wall meets the slab and where there are seams in the
siding.
Finally, all of the
shell surface area gets a 6" layer of high-quality
fiberglass insulation. This includes the wall areas
and the entire inside of the roof area. Cracks and
gaps between the studs and the door jam of the
outside door get stuffed with fiberglass.
Dry Walling
the Shell Walls:
Before the dry wall
is installed, any electrical boxes needed for
switches and outlets are installed. These backs and
sides of these boxes should be wrapped in fiberglass
insulation to prevent sound leakage. Duct tape can
be used to keep the fiberglass in place. The
fiberglass should lap-out a half-inch in front of
the box so that the installation of the dry-wall
compacts the fiberglass, making a good sound seal.
The openings in the dry-wall for the electrical
boxes should be closely and accurately cut.
All of the shell
walls will be dry walled. All dry walling will be
applied in two layers of 8'x4' half inch dry wall
sheets. The first layer will have the seams running
vertically. This layer needs to be sealed with tape
and joint compound, to get a good seal between
sheets and between the sheets and slab. The second
layer is applied with the seams running
horizontally. The final layer is sealed with tape
and joint compound.
Main
Isolation Wall:
Next, we install
the main wall that isolates the Studio from the
Control Room (per
Figure 1) This wall
is a double-stud wall with an inner and outer set of
studs placed two inches apart. As per the figure,
the studs are arranged in a staggered manner so that
the vertical studs of the outer wall are placed
between the vertical studs of the inner wall. Any
opening for electrical boxes (etc.) in the inner
wall should be 4 feet away from any opening put into
the outer wall.
This main isolation
wall goes from the floor to the roof. The inner and
outer set of studs each get 6" fiberglass
insulation. Dry-walling is done to the inner-surface
of the inner wall and the outer surface of the outer
wall. Each surface will be two-layers of half-inch
dry wall installed in the same way as the drywall
sheets were installed for the shell walls. The
isolation wall is well-sealed to both the roof, and
the slab floor.
Control Room
Window:
The window between
the Control Room and the Studio is actually two
separate windows that do not physically touch. Each
window is installed in its own frame and set in a
felt or cork filled channel. A felt runner can be
placed between the windows to dress up the gap
between the panes.
For proper
isolation, it is important that the windows are each
thick and of different thickness. We recommend (as a
minimum) that one pane be 3/8" thick and the other
pane be 1/4 inch thick. The different thickness
means that the two windows tend to vibrate at
different frequencies.
The window on the
studio side should slant down so that the bottom of
the window is 3 to 4 inches into the opening
compares to the top. This slant helps with sound
isolation and helps control reflections of
instruments' sound off of the studio side of the
window.
Inner Walls:
A double inner stud
wall is placed whenever a Control Room, Studio or
Isolation Room wall is an outside wall of the shell
garage. These walls are places two inches from the
outer wall, have 6 inches of fiberglass and are
covered with two layers of sheet drywall. Single
stud walls will separate the Control Room from the
Entrance Room and the Isolation Rooms from the
Studio and each other. The single stud walls are
packed with fiberglass and covered with two drywall
layers on both sides. All of these walls use similar
construction techniques to the other walls making
sure that each layer of drywall is well-sealed.
These walls are 8' high.
Doors should be
solid core with weather stripping for an air-tight
seal. Gaps and cracks between the studs and door
jams should be fiberglass stuffed.
Ceilings:
All of the ceilings
are suspended ceiling construction with porous
(absorbent) acoustic tiles. It is suggested that 2"
fiberglass sheeting be placed above the suspended
acoustic panels.
Any lighting
fixtures that extend into the ceiling should be
wrapped with fiberglass. Any access holes for
fixtures and cables cut into the ceiling tiles
should have cracks/gaps stuffed with fiberglass.
Electrical:
You will want to
provide a 90 amp (minimum) service panel for your
project studio. Off of this service, you will want
to run a minimum of four 20 amp circuits. Circuits
should be run in metal conduit. Non metallic
electrical cabling often doesn't meet electrical
codes and, more importantly, radiates a strong
magnetic field that
can be picked by audio equipment and wiring. An easy
to use flexible conduit can be purchased that
already has wires installed in the conduit; The
greater expense of this type of cabling is well
worth it.
Circuits 1 & 2:
These circuits are used for lighting and for any
"office" plugs in the Entrance Room that are used
for office equipment. It is especially important
that a copier be on a circuit that doesn't have any
studio/control room equipment plugs. Keeping the
audio equipment electrically separate from the
lighting & office equipment will allow dimmers to be
used with the lighting.
Lighting is
probably best accomplished with track lighting.
Alternatively, in-ceiling fixtures may be used. In
any case, the lighting should be incandescent, not
florescent.
Circuit 3: This
circuit is for your cooling and heating. You can
easily verify that one circuit is sufficient if the
heating is a gas forced-air furnace. If electrical
heat is installed, more heating circuits and a
larger central service panel will be required.
Circuit 4: This
circuit is for your audio equipment. Studio plugs
that will be used for synthesizers and guitar
amplifiers are hooked into this circuit. It is
important that the ground wire of every plug be
separately run back to the service panel and there
is a separate ground wire in each run. Do not count
on the conduit properly grounding the plug. You can
get away with as little as 2 to 3 plugs, using heavy
duty extension cords and power strips to branch the
power out to where it is needed.
Heating/Cooling:
Heating/Cooling is
probably best accomplished by a small forced-air
furnace/central air unit installed in the Entrance
room. Because of the large amount of insulation, a
relatively small capacity until can be used. To
determine the exact size, consult with a
heating/cooling contractor or building materials
supplier.
Lined ducts should
branch out close to the unit and be separately run
to each room that has a set of registers. Using
lined ducts and separately running them, greatly
reduces sound transmission through the duct work.
Generally, try to use a duct size somewhat larger
that a contractor would recommend; the air flow out
of large ducts is slower and therefore quieter.
Any openings in
walls or ceilings for ducts and registers must be
packaged with fiberglass to help maintain a sound
barrier.
In
Conclusion:
This article has
reached it's size limit.
As stated, you
should be able to obtain a professional, usable
studio converted from your under-used garage area.
The result may not be good enough to record metal
bands at midnight in a crowded urban area, but you
should be able to
mix at a reasonable
monitor volumes late into the night.
I am experienced
enough to know that people will want to use
shortcuts to save money. If you are tempted to do
this, try to get the installation as close as
possible to the plan. This is a relatively
inexpensive proposition, especially if you are doing
the labor yourself. If you have to save money, try
cutting down on heating/cooling and lighting that
don't effect sound quality. Remember that it is more
expensive to try and bring a poor job up to snuff
than it is to do it right the first time.
|