DSP
BOB DENNIS ON DIGITAL SIGNAL PROCESSING

013 - Equalization Envelopes - Part 1
Applying EQ to a signal, changes the gain at a band of frequencies for both loud and soft passages. Using EQ as control signal with a dynamics processor, however, can allow you to equalize loud passages differently than soft passages.
  

Introduction

Equalization is a powerful tool for evening out the tone of instruments and mixes, as well as giving instruments an "edge" to their sound. If, for instance, a resonance in the instrument gives it a funny color, reducing the frequency of the resonance gives a much more even and desirable sound.

The classic example of this is a resonance that can occurs when you put a microphone inside a kick drum. The resonance (at about 400 Hz) tends to make the kick drum sound like a big oatmeal box. When you listen to the kick from a distance it doesn't sound like a Quaker Oats instrument, but the sound picked up microphone sure does. Reducing 400 Hz with EQ smoothes it right out and gives you a very present sound without the cardboard.

Limitations

In the kick drum example the microphone placement amplified frequencies that were being generated by the drum. There are other situations that occur in recording where an extra sound at a particular frequency (called a "formant") is generated and is not really part of the sound generation mechanism. These don't necessarily respond well to using equalization alone.

One example of this kind of situation is the "S" sound generated by singers when pronouncing the S. The air rushing through the teeth make a spike at about 7-8kHz. This only occurs when the singer sings a "S." Reducing 7 kHz with EQ reduces this frequency's level when the singer is singing the "S" but also when they aren't. Since 7 kHz is close to the "presence" frequency you wind up with a dull vocal - something that cannot happen in a mix.

Another example of this situation is the microphone "pop" that can occur with close-micing a vocal. The blast of air generated by the vocalist pronouncing hard consonants (P, B, D, etc.) make very low-frequency thumping sounds - microphone "pops".  Again this cannot be removed with standard EQ without adversly affecting the tone of the overall vocal.

The Dynamics Processing Side Chain

The side Chain input of a dynamics processor (offten called a "key" input) can be used to reduce level during vocal S's and mic pops. The side chain is the control circuit of the dynamic processor. The dynamic processor changes gain according to the signal sent to the side chain. In a normal configuration the input to the dynamic processing also feeds the side chain. But if the dynamic processor has a "key" input, putting a signal into that input make it respond to that signal, not the input signal.

The Basic Deesser

You can buy deessers. A deesser is a dynamics processing unit that has an equalization inserted into the sidechain that boosts 7 kHz. Now the unit will reduce gain whenever there is a spike at 7 kHz. Since it is only in play when there is an "S" it leaves the vocal alone at any other time. A Deesser can be built in a DAW program by creating an aux track that has a boost at 7kHz and then feeding this into the key input of a compressor via a buss.

Using this configuration, you can also handle other problems like vocal pops, simply by changing the frequency of the control equalization - the "equalization envelope." For vocal pops, use a boost at 50 Hz, with shelf equalization.

Why Not Just Buy a Dessser?

There are hardware solutions and you can even get plug-ins that will do deessing and even "tune" the frequency of the equalization envelope controlling the gain reduction. In today's DAW programs, the addition of an outboard hardware unit is extra gear that the sound has to go through and you'll probably have to convert your digital recording to analog and then back to digital. This much alteration of the signal will also noticably degrade the signal. As far as another plug-in - why spend the money when you can make a deesser, depopper, etc when you can make youer standard plug-ins do the job and even get a better result for your particular production?

Some Tips

Usually large boosts of the frequency you use as your equalization are desirable. Higher Q values (between 2 - 4) also help you isolate the gain reduction to just the problem spikes.

Anytime you have a note or a sound that is repeatedly loud, an equalization envelope in a dynamics processor is a way you can correct this annoying problem. Here's a list of some of the equalization envelopes I have used successfully in mixing:

7 kHz - Deessing
50 Hz - Removing vocal pops
4 kHz - Evening out a sax part
100 Hz - Evening out a bass line

Using A Spectrum Analyzer

One of the tools that most DAW setups have (or should have) is a spectrum analyzer program. This program will show you the energy in the audio at different frequencies.

You can take any track and look at it playing the part. If the line is uneven, you will see a frequency spike anytime a particular pitch is played. You also can see, for instance, the exact frequency that the annoying "S" is at - and this varies from singer to singer. Using this tool can let you exactly tune the equalization envelope to what you need.

Ozone3 Spectrum Analysis Screen



Audio Demos

Next week I will publish some audio demos and Pro Tools setups for using equalization envelopes - stay tuned.


wise Bob Sr.
 

Copyright © 2006 by Robert Dennis - ALL RIGHTS RESERVED
USE OF ANY LINKED ARTICLE SUBJECT TO USER AGREEMENT