Let me point out
something that should sound like a given: every aspiring artist or band should
have some means to distinguish themselves from other artists or bands. Most
artists and bands, even when they believe they have made such an impact fail
to secure that distinction with a procedure that legalizes their uniqueness:
trademark registration. |
A trademark is,
literally, a “mark of trade”. It is a graphic depiction--a name, drawing,
logo, unique spelling, etc.--that is used to set apart competing interests in
the marketplace so as to avoid confusion by consumers. Trademarks usually
protect tangible items--items which can physically be touched-- such as
a chair, car, or computer. When it comes to providing a means of
distinguishing between, for example, those who provide intangible
services--such as upholstering a chair, repairing a car, or programming a
computer--a “servicemark” is then used. A servicemark is what musicians would
use to protect their unique and distinctive style of playing. |
According to the United
States Patent and Trademark Office www.uspto.gov), a trademark or servicemark
is only considered protected when actually utilized in commerce. For example,
a band cannot get protection on a name they are planning on using at some
later date; they must actually have the name in use before that protected
status can be conferred upon it. This differs from copyright law in that an
item is NOT protected the instant it is created. Where trademark law and
copyright appear similar is that registration in either instance gives an
added layer of protection, a layer that would come in handy if and when a
violation occurred resulting in legal action. |
A trademark or
servicemark is also established based on “territory” and “priority” meaning
where was it used first and when. This means that if your band has been
performing in the great state of Michigan as “The Desperations” since July of
2000, a band in Alaska with the same name which has been performing since 1994
could safely--and legally-- use the same name since the territory you perform
in is far removed from that of the competing band. Where a problem might arise
is when the Michigan “Desperations” become a national act and the Alaskan
version complains. The Alaskan band could file a lawsuit to prohibit the
Michigan band from using that name since they have established prior use of
the name since 1994. Moreover, the Alaskan band could stop any other band from
using similar names like “The Desperados”, “The Desperates”, “The Despicables”,
etc. if they could convince a court that the similar names could cause
confusion in the marketplace. |
Registration of a
trademarked name comes in handy here because it establishes when the applicant
first applied with the US government for protection of the mark. If the
Alaskan band had not registered the name but the Michigan band did, the latter
could enjoin (stop) the former from using the name, even though the former
used the name first. |
To prevent a situation
like the above example, at the USPTO site there is a search engine entitled
the Trademark Electronic Search System (TESS) which lets the applicant know if
a proposed name is in use already. Although this is fast and relatively easy
way to research a name, USPTO advises to have a more thorough search done
using an attorney familiar with trademarks and servicemarks. TESS only reviews
those who have taken the time and expense to register a name; it does not give
information on those who use a name but have not filed it with the
government. In addition to TESS, there are several websites such as
bandname.com which do a similar function, but as with TESS, they are by no
means thorough. |
As mentioned before,
copyright laws and the procedure to register a copyright are vastly different
from trademark laws and registration. This is evident when one realizes the
expense involved in properly researching and registering a trade- or
servicemark. If a band hires an attorney to do a thorough search of the
proposed name, the fee an attorney may charge could range from a few hundred
to a few thousand dollars, depending on how much time the attorney takes in
researching the name. Further expense is accrued when the registration
information is finally submitted to Washington. Fees currently hover around
$350. These costs are the number one reason that many bands and artists do not
register their names for protection, a move which could potentially
|
be disastrous if they
are forced to change their long-held names due to a lawsuit from another band
or artist. |
For those musicians
starting out who have at least done a nominal search of a name using TESS or
other websites and have found no competing or similar names, they can alert
the rest of the world of their usage of a particular name by using the letters
“tm” (or “sm”) next to their group’s name or logo. These letters inform all
who may be interested that the name or logo is being claimed as a means of
conducting commerce, and therefore should not be infringed upon. These
letters, however, have no legal protection. When the band finally registers
the name, the USPTO gives them permission to alert the world of this legal
protection by using the letter “r” in a circle next to the name. This is
another way that copyright is different from trademarks. A person writing a
song can use the letter “c” in a circle without registering the work with
Washington and still be protected by the full letter of the law. No one can
use the letter “r” in a circle legally without first registering the work with
the USPTO. |
|
For bands starting
out, it is best to get as much information about trade- and servicemarks
before attaching themselves to a name. This advice applies even more so if a
particular logo is being used. Drawings could be viewed very subjectively by
someone and that person could claim that it causes confusion with an already
established logo and file suit. Bands and artists should consult with an
attorney who specializes in trademarks before proceeding any further. It would
be a shame to have to throw out years of image-building--and possibly fan
support since the band now has to alert them of their new name--because a band
is forced to discontinue using a name or logo. The money invested now in
establishing your uniqueness and distinctiveness is nothing compared with
having to do it all over again. |